Paladin Guide, Why Enmity and Shield Oath Are Broken Currently

http://ventusinvictus.blogspot.com/2...din-guide.html

I have delayed posting info for a month on Enmity testing because there are factors I just cannot account for.

In small detail, I generate more threat than my lalafel friend (and we aren't talking a sliver on the threat meter, we are talking 25% or so).

Same Items, no Buffs, switching who takes swing, different abilities.

He had to have 21 STR more than I in order take hate over me using the same actions.

This baseline issue has occured with multiple races, even my own race.

I believe it may be related to some RNG factor on the character, the god we choose, birthdate, some other stat.

Please review the testing and find an error, otherwise SE has screwed the pooch hard.

Bumping because it's a shame this doesn't have people talking.

Very interesting. Bumping because I want to see if Square addresses these findings as "Statistically Significant".

I'm not understanding what is happening in the "Testing" section.... did one person pull by flashing? both flashing? any auto-attacks used? if you're just walking up to aggro did the aggro go on the first person, or immediately jump to the second every time without auto-attacking? full rotations on all mobs?

...maybe it is obvious to most, but after looking at the section it wasn't quite clear to me what was actually happening to you guys, other than mobs do not like cat tails :P

just took a look at the pics

didnt read your blog much

just want to say

i think

the extra enmity provided by shield oath doesnt necessarily mean it will let you generate more hate with it than without.

its there because it is to counter the output dmg you lost from dmg reduction effect you get from shield oath.

So Paladin's are now saying their class is broken? I love it lol.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by The_Brute

So Paladin's are now saying their class is broken? I love it lol.

---

Oh, he's not saying they class is broken. He's saying one of their abilities looks like it's not functioning consistently or as intended, aka broken. There's nothing wrong with that.

Yes Yes keep get SE attention

So they can revamp (rebalanced) Tank rolls

Keep get SE attention man!

You know what's under powered about Paladin's? A stun move that is on GCD. WTF?!

You say you tested this with someone else with the same race and gear?
Did you always out-threat that person, too?
If yes to both, could you try this again, but instead give lead to the other person?