Handing in Guild Tasks rewards not given correctly

Platform: Windows
ISP: BT
Type of Internet Connection: ADSL
Internet Connection Speed: 1Mbps
Date & Time: Multiple times during past week
Frequency: Often
Character Name: Eruantien Draugole
Race: Duskwight Elezen
World: Fabul
Class/Skill Rank: Multple classes
Physical Level: 50
Area and Coordinates: Several Guilds (Miner, Botanist, Goldsmith, Carpenters)
Party or Solo: Solo
NPC Name: Guild Leaders of above mentioned guilds
Monster Name:
In-Game Time:
Steps:

1. Look at Task Board
2. Get Items required for Task
3. Hand in items to guild leader
4. NPC states I will be rewarded with items (items that have been said when error occurs, 100 wind shards, 5000 gil, 100 earth shards)
5. NPC hands me rewards (items recieved bronze wire, 100 wind shards, 5000 gil respectively from previous statement)

Let me know if you need more detail

It is more a inconsistency in what they say they offer and when they give you the reward.

When they offer the reward, they say they will give it to 'a select few' adventurers. however when they actually give you the reward, they say 'as promised.

here is the txt from the carpenter guild:

A'naidjaa: Excellent! Then bring to me a single pine dagger grip. The guild is prepared to offer a select few 100 earth shards as recompense for their efforts.
*Hand in pine dagger grip
A'naidjaa: The deed is done, then. The guild couldn't be more pleased with your work. Here is your reward, as promised.
*Given a spool of copper wire
A'naidjaa: You are turning out to be rather useful, I must say. Here, a token of the guild's appreciation.
*Given 3500 gil

I have experienced the same on Figaro.

don't feel too bad i can do the r30 alc quest and instead of getting the 3000 guild marks they subtracted 3000 alc guild marks. at least you did receive an item lol.

Greetings Eruantien!

Thank you for taking the time to fill out all the information we request! I do apologize if those types of rewards has been causing any trouble or frustration. We will gladly forward the concern to be looked into. Any updates will be posted within the forum as they become available. Thanks again!