Square Enix GAME developer's I have a game design question.

It was my understanding from several mentions that elemental resistance was removed from the game. Yet Bards get the skill "Foe Requiem" - It is a complete waste of a skill in the game from my opinion and bad design choice. It needs to be remade! However if there is a use for it I would like a developer to clear my confusion or players to debate on the viability of the skill.

Poisin from BRDs does more damage with that skill up.

By Elemental Resistances being removed they meant certain enemies being strong or weak to specific elements. For example, black mages would be completely dead weight in a fight with a Fire-resistant enemy. There is still an elemental resistance mechanic, though, that reduces or increases damage from spells, just not specific elements.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Estellios

By Elemental Resistances being removed they meant certain enemies being strong or weak to specific elements. For example, black mages would be completely dead weight in a fight with a Fire-resistant enemy. There is still an elemental resistance mechanic, though, that reduces or increases damage from spells, just not specific elements.

---

Thats because they were not gonna put enough effort into the design of all the enemys, hence the "trash" design. Instead of simply giving BLM access to all the elements and give WHM/CON a light based or non elemental nuke like the one ARC has, they felt the need to split them up so they didnt have to deal with the elemental wheel which exists in basically every FF. The slash/pierce/blunt i understand more, because we are sadly locked to one weapon type, though that could be fixed easy enough with things like the early 1.0 ideas of stances and different types of each weapon (ex: dagger = pierce, shield skills blunt, gladius slash, MNK can do the same or do stances pure and simple, DRG could have attacks that are a little of each based on what part of the spear you hit with..ect) Of course the bonus wouldnt be huge enough to make a massive difference, but it would help.

but this game lacks major depth in combat. Stats are super simple, the gear is super simple and linear, the enemys are trash design so of course they are simple minded. Its just over and over a game for the simple minded players who dont wanna think when they mash a rotation...like every other MMO these days.

And bard in general is basically just a ranger with some simple buffs, they pretty much took the thought and true support role out of the job even compared to 1.0.

Bumping for more discussion -.-

This is a stealth discussion about bards being boring? Or is it about elemental resistance?

elemental resistance.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Zanfire

Thats because they were not gonna put enough effort into the design of all the enemys, hence the "trash" design. Instead of simply giving BLM access to all the elements and give WHM/CON a light based or non elemental nuke like the one ARC has, they felt the need to split them up so they didnt have to deal with the elemental wheel which exists in basically every FF. The slash/pierce/blunt i understand more, because we are sadly locked to one weapon type, though that could be fixed easy enough with things like the early 1.0 ideas of stances and different types of each weapon (ex: dagger = pierce, shield skills blunt, gladius slash, MNK can do the same or do stances pure and simple, DRG could have attacks that are a little of each based on what part of the spear you hit with..ect) Of course the bonus wouldnt be huge enough to make a massive difference, but it would help.

but this game lacks major depth in combat. Stats are super simple, the gear is super simple and linear, the enemys are trash design so of course they are simple minded. Its just over and over a game for the simple minded players who dont wanna think when they mash a rotation...like every other MMO these days.

And bard in general is basically just a ranger with some simple buffs, they pretty much took the thought and true support role out of the job even compared to 1.0.

---

This x100000000. I'm going to stick around, but dear god does this game's combat need to improve. Every time I think of the wasted potential wrought by the limit break system I die a little inside.

-pops in-
Doc, damn that cat gif is funny LOL
-pops out-