Dagger Soup gives 5 exp

ISP:
Time Warner Cable

Type of Internet Connection:
Optic Fiber

Internet Connection Speed:
50mbit/s
Date & Time:
9:32est 8/31/2013

Frequency:
Always

Character Name:
Surreal Soul

Race:
Miqo'te Female

World:
Sargatanas

Class/Level:
47Cul

Area and Coordinates:
Limsia lower deckss

Party or Solo:
Solo

NPC Name:
None

Monster Name:
None

In-Game Time:
unknown

Steps:
I crafted a dagger soup for the first time and received this message in log
[6:17 p.m.]You synthesize a bowl of dagger soup.
[6:17 p.m.]You gain 6 (+20%) experience points.
[6:17 p.m.]You gain 5 experience points.

I tried it again and got this as an result
[6:18 p.m.]You synthesize a bowl of dagger soup.
[6:18 p.m.]You gain 10 (+100%) experience points.

It seems very odd that a level 50 craft gives almost no exp what so ever.