Weapon Advice for Immortal Flames WAR

Hey all. I'm a fairly fresh WAR still wielding the Lv 48 D.Bhuj. I was wondering if anyone can order the following axes from best to worst:

1.) Flame Sergeant's Axe
2.) Garuda's Scream
3.) Malignant Mogaxe
4.) Ifrit's Battleaxe
5.) Giantsgall Waraxe (any single melds)
6.) Flame Lieutenant's Axe

Don't bother throwing Bravura in the mix; that won't be happening anytime soon (too much commitment at the moment).

I currently have enough seals to drop on the Sergeant's Axe, though I'm saving 25K for Mess with the Goat, Get the Horns and potentially then the Lieutenant's.

Thanks for the input everyone :)

Bear in mind, this ranking doesn't account for any of your other gear. Ultimately, your other gear will determine which axe is best for you. So based on the stats of the weapon alone here's how I'd rank them.


Flame Lieutenant's Axe*
Giantsgall War Axe (with a meld of 80ish + attack power)
Garuda's Scream
Flame Sergeant's Axe
Ifrit's Axe
Malignant Mogaxe
Giantsgall War Axe (with no melds)

*Remember you must account for the fact that by equipping 4 other pieces of GC gear your STR and VIT will mostly likely take a hit, and would change the ranking.

Here, you can see how everything adds up with my current gear. I have 324 STR and 318 VIT:
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/...1E&output=html

For the weapon's potential look at the "Full Potential as Weight" column.

Thanks for the reply!

Just for clarification, do you have Flame Lieutenant's Axe in that order WITHOUT the extra flame pieces/bonus? If not, where would you rank it without gear bonus?

It shows with and without.

Got it. Thanks!