Character Creation Feedback Thread

So I have 1 Phial of Fantasia and several characters to transform into. I'd like your opinion on them and which one is superior.

First, my Hyur Midlander:
https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/...8e83168e_o.png
Height: 70
Muscle Tone: 75
Skin Color: 24, 4
Hairstyle: 2, 4 original; 7, 2 current
Hair Color: 1, 4
Face: 6
Jaw: 4
Eye Shape: 3
Iris Size: Small
Eye Color: 1, 5
Eyebrows: 3
Nose: 4
Mouth: 1
Lip Color: Light 6, 5
Facial Features: Beard
Tattoos: none
Tattoo Color: n/a
Face Paint: 1
Face Paint Color: Light 1, 8
Voice: 5

Then my catboy:
https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/...2b15b39d_o.png
Height: 100
Skin Color: 24, 6
Tail Shape: 1, 3
Tail Length: 100
Hairstyle: 3, 2 original; 3, 4 alternate; Great Lengths new
Hair Color: 1, 8
Face: 4
Jaw: 1
Eye Shape: 3
Iris Size: Large
Eye Color: 24, 8
Eyebrows: 4
Nose: 4
Mouth: 2
Lip Color: Dark 7, 6
Facial Features: none
Tattoos: none
Tattoo Color: n/a
Face Paint: none
Face Paint Color: n/a
Voice: 5

This fella came up one time when I clicked Randomize Appearance, and I liked his style quite a lot. I tweaked his eyes a bit to match their color to his tattoos.
https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/...0d7db35c_o.png
Height: 70
Muscle Tone: 100 (originally 99)
Skin Color: 8, 8
Hairstyle: 7, 2
Hair Color: 13, 8
Face: 2
Jaw: 4
Eye Shape: 6
Iris Size: Small
Eye Color: 8, 2
Eyebrows: 5
Nose: 4
Mouth: 2
Lip Color: Light 2, 6
Facial Features: Bridge scar
Tattoos: Both
Tattoo Color: 8, 6
Face Paint: none
Face Paint Color: n/a
Voice: 6

And finally my generic Highlander:
https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/...8b347fa0_o.png
Height: 0
Muscle Tone: 50
Skin Color: 24, 7
Hairstyle: 4, 5
Hair Color: 1, 8
Face: 4
Jaw: 2
Eye Shape: 3
Iris Size: Large
Eye Color: 9, 8
Eyebrows: 1
Nose: 1
Mouth: 4
Lip Color: Light 6, 8
Facial Features: Mustache, beard
Tattoos: none
Tattoo Color: n/a
Face Paint: Painted eyebrows
Face Paint Color: Dark 1, 8
Voice: 1

Any opinions on which one I should go with? And any recommended modifications to any of the above?