So here is the thing:
Fisher lvl 59
Gathering 442
Perception 354
Gulleye level: 4
Skyfishing: Yes
Cloudfishing: yes
Hellfishing: Yes
Aetherfishing: Yes
Last Question Completed: One Man's Fish is Another Man's Poison
Bait Equiped: Red Balloon
Location: Mok Oogl Island lvl 56
Problem: No matter what I do how I do it or where on the island i do it it will not let me fish at Mok Oogl Island. All it keeps saying is "You can sense something swimming below, but are uncertain where."
Question: Is there something special about this spot i need to know about to fish here or is there just some bug that is preventing me from fishing.