how would you like FF14 anime?

should it be about player playing the actual MMO game (.hack,SAO)
or should the world be an actual world people live in (ragnarok the animation)

Hmmmmm tough call.

If it was about the people playing a game would it be a comedy?

The Misadventures of the Derplander


Also: I'd prefer if it was more like RO the Animation. I have...opinions about SAO... and still in my eyes .hack got it right and really can't do the whole "people playing MMOs" thing any better than that so... and everyone and their mom has an anime like that, more of the world of the game is "real' please.

I wouldn't be opposed to an anime following a bit of lore that we haven't seen. Perhaps another adventurer and their gang going on a different journey related to the travels of the Miqo'te or Au Ra when they first landed in Eorzea? That would be fascinating. I wouldn't touch anything that follows the current plot that we're following, though.

I was working on a dojinshi based on Alphinaud and Alisae called "My twin sister can't be this cute?" but decided to scrap it.

I'd rather it be unique characters (adventurers) living in the world of FF14 with maybe the occasional cameos or mention of main npcs than it be players being transported into the gameworld

If it was like RO the Animation or Log Horizon (sans "trapped in the vg world" story) it could be very well done. If it was done like SAO (again, sans the "trapped" story) I'd be disappointed.

I would like a spin-off about the 1.0 storyline and the Scions backstory, not us.

Either random adventurers running parallel to the WoL's actions or something from the backstory. War of the Magi or Fall of Meracydia could be neat.

There's always the "hero summoned from another world" trope.

Hydaelyn summoning forth the will-be Warrior of Light from another world. That kind of thing.

In either case, I'd like the FFXIV world to be (a) reality in this hypothetical anime, not just a game. It makes the happenings in any story it might have much more impactful.