I liked Revenant's Toll more than Idyllshire

It was more spacious, had better music IMO, mounts were allowed there, and it changed over time.

:(

I agree 100%.. It really was a much better area to chill at for our high levels. :/

I'm sure Idyllshire will change every other major patch. But yeah I'm not liking that it's instanced since those multiple idyllshire quests were so annoying

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by myahele

I'm sure Idyllshire will change every other major patch. But yeah I'm not liking that it's instanced since those multiple idyllshire quests were so annoying

---

It has to be instanced though. Revenant Toll could only be developed so much to a point where any more models and you'd start to tax low-end systems like the ps3. By instancing Idyllshire, not only do you make it load-heavy when a lot of people are there buy if they choose to expand off of it they aren't restricted as much in size. Afterall, Ul'dah is instanced for a reason and not just a part of Thanalan.

It also sucks that Hinterlands is the only zone that does not have a sanctuary...

I dislike them both, I wish they'd just add the vendors to Ishgard. The daytime music in Idyllshire drives me insane, not to mention the people who keep spamming loud abilities. >_< Ishgard also has my favourite OST from this expansion so far.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by CGMidlander

It was more spacious, had better music IMO, mounts were allowed there, and it changed over time.

:(

---

Give the Goblins time to rebuild it.
Even Revenant's Tolls was at the beginning just a handfull tents.

no incentive to hang out in ishgard after the story ends kind of sucks. idyllshire is a dump.

I'm tired of these encampments. The Toll was no different than Idyllshare for me, except that Idyllshare is worse because it's all broken and has the unbearably ugly goblin camps. I wonder if we will ever get a REAL city or HQ where we can spend tomes and chill that doesn't look like forgotten ruins or a stone refuge in a radioactive area.

Now now, there is no need to talk like that about Idyllshire. After all Revenant's toll was even worse when it started.