WAR MT + PLD OT vs. PLD MT + WAR OT in terms of DPS
I see this thrown around a lot and though the general consensus seems to favor PLD MT + WAR OT, I see a lot of comments in the other direction as well. Some of the arguments I generally read are flawed because they'll state things such as "WAR with STR accs beats PLD with tanking accs" and things of that nature.
Fight or Flight and Berserk are available regardless of which job is tanking, but the main differences lie in the following:
WAR MT loses 25% damage due to Defiance, but can use Unchained every 120 seconds to regain it for 20 seconds. WAR MTs also have varying extra critical %.
PLD MT loses 50 potency on auto attacks due to being in Shield Oath over Sword Oath.
I'd like to hear from stat junkies who crunch numbers (if there are any).