Suggestion: make materia melds give a small boost to iLV

Given that iLV is not just a cosmetic/bragging measuring stick but serves an actual in game purpose (of limiting certain content and participation in certain groups), I believe that materia melding should appropriately reflect an added increase in item's potency by increasing its iLV.

Crafted iLV70 gear penta melded with two-three Materia IV and the rest in materias III or II are almost always superior to dropped iLV80 and can sometimes rival iLV90 gear.
If you deck yourself out with all 5 accessories like that, your overall iLV rating really does not reflect the quality and effectiveness of your gear set, capping you at iLV80 even if your entire left side is at iLV90.

Could we have a system that appropriately adjusts the iLV of an item as you slot more and more materias into it?

they made the gear have a stat cap to prevent a item becoming a high ilvl then it was this would do the opposite of what they want.

I think they shoudl just make gear have materia slots in it too. Tailor encounters to not only be around bis gear as you level, but also to tailor preferred gameplay via materia slots (imagine Allagan gear with 3 materia slots)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Flyojumper

Given that iLV is not just a cosmetic/bragging measuring stick but serves an actual in game purpose (of limiting certain content and participation in certain groups), I believe that materia melding should appropriately reflect an added increase in item's potency by increasing its iLV.

Crafted iLV70 gear penta melded with two-three Materia IV and the rest in materias III or II are almost al....

---

unfortunately ilvl is based off the primary stats and not the bonus ones. and those are capped.

I am aware of caps to stats, but you can more than make up for the 2 pts in main stat that you lose by using an iLV70 instead of an iLV80 by slotting materia IVs and boosting secondary stats by 12+, without counting the added benefits of adding vitality or an extra stat into the mix. Penta melded crafted iLV70 gear are a hell of a lot better than darklight (and very often better than iLV80) yet their iLV does not reflect their effectiveness.
It sounds silly to equip some iLV80 accessory just to be able to join that Bahamut Coil party you see on the board that requires overall iLV83 to join, only to switch back to your superior iLV70 crafted gear when you have joined the party.

it's simple ilvl 80 is better then ilvl 70 no matter how much you meld it. yes it gives the stats you specifically want but it does not make it better then ilvl80 no matter how much you meld it.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Musashidon

it's simple ilvl 80 is better then ilvl 70 no matter how much you meld it. yes it gives the stats you specifically want but it does not make it better then ilvl80 no matter how much you meld it.

---

Here's an example:
BRD Ultima Necklace: iLV80
11 dex
14 crit
10 accuracy

I can meld an iLV70 necklace and penta meld it which will have these stats:
10 vit
9 str
9 dex
12 crit
8 det
9 skill speed
9 accuracy

(I actually have one of those)
You trade off 2 dex, 2 crit and 1 acc for 8 det, 9 skill speed, 10vit and 9 str.
You can plug in the +2dex and +2 crit you get on the iLV80 in the damage formula all you want, it will not overpower the 8 det and 9 skill speed you get from the iLV70 crafted. And that's without the extra benefits of 10 vit and 9 str.

Another example just for kicks:
Ilv80 Ultima BRD ring:
11 dex
10 det
10 accuracy

VS

Crafted iLV70 ring:
8 vit
9 str
9 dex
12 crit
8 det
9 skill speed
12 accuracy

By using the iLV70 you give away 2 dex and 2 det and you get in return: 8 vit, 9 str, 12 crit, 9 skill speed, 2 accuracy. How can you even consider the iLV80 to be superior? The dps on the iLV70 is higher, the accuracy is higher, you get more vit and even some uneeded str.

It is a slight oversight with the ilevel requirement for events and also makes the crafted ilevel70 gear even more useless since you are stuck to being ilevel 70 even if you had a full set of ilevel 70 gear that had 5 melds on every piece possible.

It would make sense for materia melds to effect the item lv for those pieces of armor, all they would need to do is have the "base item level" which would be the attribute limit of said item and then the "Materia item level" which would be the current item level that would effect the players item lv rank.

At least this way players using ilevel 70 gear with 5 melds on it will be able to have a realistic item level rather than the one represented as the base.

You could just ask the leader of the party finder to manually invite you if he set the ilvl too high and say you have penta melded gear and see if he takes you.