Request for Utsusemi

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Wolfie

I will keep talking as if it did, because it did. PLD was a second rate tank for everything except the dozen HNMs where it eeked out a victory over NIN. You haven't yet showed me any proof that PLD was on equal footing with NIN, and i have hard numbers that showed that NIN was faring better than PLD.

---

For one, because I'm not talking about FFXI, Ninja OR Paladin - for the 832948923489th time. And all of a sudden you went from 8 NM's to 12. Randomly increase argument by a factor of 4!

Why are we even talking which from PLD or NIN is better XD? I thought it was about how broken Utsusemi was or in general how shadow tanking was far superior than blood tanking.

or how it would increase survival by superior margin if OP is still on bard subject.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Wolfie

k ur dumb, i'm so ashamed it took me 8 pages in this topic and 4 pages in another to figure it out.

---

Congratulations! I figured that much about you back with your first post.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Chardrizard

Why are we even talking which from PLD or NIN is better XD? I thought it was about how broken Utsusemi was or in general how shadow tanking was far superior than blood tanking.

or how it would increase survival by superior margin if OP is still on bard subject.

---

Holy Christ! Are we talking about tanking in this thread??!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Firon

lol no you don't like i said PLD/NIN took less dmg than nin no matter what you say and did more dmg.

---

http://i.imgur.com/U2ILD.jpg

You don't judge a tank on a single criteria in a single scenario. Please tell me you're not serious with this reply.

If anything, we can say that in 9 pages thus far, 100% of its participants have a major problem with reading comprehension. I think it speaks for a subconscious desire to return to FFXI.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Xoo

For one, because I'm not talking about FFXI, Ninja OR Paladin - for the 832948923489th time. And all of a sudden you went from 8 NM's to 12. Randomly increase argument by a factor of 4!

---

It's not a "factor of 4", that's multiplying by 4.

And I said "like" a dozen. I'm not claiming 100% accuracy in the numbers of HNMs that PLD outranked NIN on, because I'm not sure of that. What I am sure of, though, is that NIN outranked PLD on the overwhelming majority of end-game situations, including non-HNM end-game.

Can you come up with some counter points that aren't strawmen?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Wolfie

It's not a "factor of 4", that's multiplying by 4.

And I said "like" a dozen. I'm not claiming 100% accuracy in the numbers of HNMs that PLD outranked NIN on, because I'm not sure of that. What I am sure of, though, is that NIN outranked PLD on the overwhelming majority of end-game situations, including non-HNM end-game.

Can you come up with some counter points that aren't strawmen?

---

Unfortunately, I cannot because I could not care less about your points since they do not address why giving Bard Utsusemi is a good/bad idea. How is it possible that you can derive that my arguments are straw man? You can't even comprehend a five-word sentence. o.O

Welp I added Xoo to my ignore list. Half the posts in this topic are gone. Guess it's time for me to stop paying attention to it, unless I want to read more intellectual posts from Chardrizard.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Firon

No pld became a blink tank.... I said an DEF base tank became a blink tank..... the skill was too good.

---

Ochain says hi.