Originally Posted by
Ehayte
My point being is that there would be a slight DPS gain from using Unchained even if you aren't tanking - you don't need a tank swap to use Unchained, and a tank swap would probably lower DPS because of the transitional 2-3 GCDs of the PLD not attacking so that you can cement enmity.
You aren't totally off-base, and I would say it really depends on the group for which is better (moving Phoenix or not), you are just confusing the point by implying contradictions.
However, this thread is about WAR DPS, not overall group DPS on T12, so....