For me it's a bit of very situational when I hand out commendations
Like when I used to have jobs to level up I just handed them out quickly to just anyone for my challenge log. Though I sometimes had to race for that when the window takes like 1-2 secs to open and adventurers already left quickly.
But nowadays outside of job leveling it so far has been for like:
* Same race or funny portrait
* A caster/healer raising a bunch of people.
* A last standing tank finishing off the last 5-10% of a boss remaining exp or a tank trying to keep me alive while I play Physical ranged.
* Healer carrying the party.
* (I can't remember well if I gave it for that while I often receive them when playing on tank) I guess doing wall to wall's very quick??
* Someone giving out a dungeon tips like how in some old dungeons (Cutter's cry & Stone Vigil) you can just run all the way to the boss and wipe there because of the wipe condition Dawntrail added to make shortcuts appear.
