Is it bad I thought of 3D Realms and Duke Nukem Forever?
Haha. Thats just a pipe dream man. :/
Yoshi-P if you're listening... The key to make your idea successful, regardless of what you decided in the end, is to:
Not use generic MMO terms when naming the system.
i.e even if you decided on a Talent Tree - don't call it a Talent Tree. Call it the Job Grid, Titles or something. Then we can all sit back and laugh as people call it "brilliant". lol
Make it a sphere grid and you have me hooked.
I like the tree idea of the original poster. It would remind me of Seiken Densetsu 3. I played that game at least 10 times through trying different things. They also had a point allotment setup. I would love it.
Hmm.. guess its been a while. Don't remember anything like this in SD3. lol
I honestly can't stand talent trees. They are rather pointless when you consider the mix/max is inevitable. You might as well have pre-determined traits and abilities. I really wouldn't like that people could respec either. Being able to go from DRK to PLD is rather lame, it would be like having 2 classes at max even though you only leveled one. They are 2 very different classes and should stay separate in my opinion.
I'd much prefer the advanced jobs and a re-haul of all current ones, set up in a more classic FF way.
I don't like skill trees either, I thought these advanced classes or jobs would help preexisting classes spells and only add new abilities/ spells from old FF games lol. TO further pigeon hole people for lack of a better term.