I've been a battleground junkie in a certain un-named MMO; I've seen it all over the years in that un-named mmo, and I'm quite fond of instanced group pvp.
With that said, if I were allowed the option to choose between PVE and PVP in FFXIV, I'd definitely go the pvp route--if it were a viable alternative, and not just some thrown together thing to try to appease pvpers.
I'll let you in on a little secret: PvPers don't really care about "lore": just throw a bunch of us into a nicely designed zone and we're more than happy to smash each other's faces in--repeatedly.
