Cracked Materia Guide

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Molly_Millions

When you take materia out of an item, you lose it.

---

Under normal circumstances yes, though the image implies that it may be possible to exchange the gear cracked materia for materia. While this may just be a direct swap out, it doesn't specify either way. Regardless, the fact that tier IV materia are going to be more rare is definitely worth taking into account when trading in things.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Tinks

Under normal circumstances yes, though the image implies that it may be possible to exchange the gear cracked materia for materia. While this may just be a direct swap out, it doesn't specify either way. Regardless, the fact that tier IV materia are going to be more rare is definitely worth taking into account when trading in things.

---

Quote:

---

2. Players will be able to exchange their cracked materia for new materia of their choosing.
* Materia that has already been affixed to gear can be converted as is.

---

This seems to imply that we can only swap the materia in place or exchange the gear for tokens.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Molly_Millions

From the test results I've seen that appears to be the case. On HQ gear, you can only add stats that are not on that gear already. For NQ gear, you can add those stats, but only as much as is on the HQ equivalent.

Using a Rubelite Ring as an example, the HQ version has +7 STR. You can't add any STR to an HQ Rubelite Ring. The NQ version has +5 STR, so you can only add +2 STR to one of those. You can, however, add +7 VIT or DEX to both an NQ or HQ Rubelite Ring.

---

Maybe we are talking about the same thing but just in case. I was thinking of something like a Cobalt Cuirass that I think as NQ gives:

STR +12
VIT +12
Parry +17

If I HQ that will all those three stats go up to the cap or might it just be some of them...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Cynthis

Maybe we are talking about the same thing but just in case. I was thinking of something like a Cobalt Cuirass that I think as NQ gives:

STR +12
VIT +12
Parry +17

If I HQ that will all those three stats go up to the cap or might it just be some of them...

---

all 3 will be at the cap.

I think they go up to

STR +15
VIT +15
Parry +20

Excellent. I need to start planning my HQ crafting gear and skill sets then:)

IMO, use HQ gear for melding good dungeon gear, use NQ for spiritbonding. Wherever you don't have darklight gear, use darksteel or equivalent for your class. That will obviously change once the really high-end recipes are introduced.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Molly_Millions

IMO, use HQ gear for melding good dungeon gear, use NQ for spiritbonding. Wherever you don't have darklight gear, use darksteel or equivalent for your class. That will obviously change once the really high-end recipes are introduced.

---

Yeah, definitely my plan. I am glad I got my Vanya and Gryphonskin gear done in 1.0. Just hope I can turn in the materia on those as well.

Come to think of it, since most of my Vanya/Gryphonskin isn't HQ, I can fill in the 2 materia spots with G5 materia of something useful but since there is no penalty for failing forbidden melds, I guess it makes sense to just plug along with low level materia to get those extra +3 INT... until you get lucky. That is probably more useful than trying to get a third G5 materia of the 6th most useful stat to stick. Not even sure I could think of a 6th particularly worthwhile stat category for BLM for example, not worth throwing G5 materia at any rate.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Cynthis

Yeah, definitely my plan. I am glad I got my Vanya and Gryphonskin gear done in 1.0. Just hope I can turn in the materia on those as well.

Come to think of it, since most of my Vanya/Gryphonskin isn't HQ, I can fill in the 2 materia spots with G5 materia of something useful but since there is no penalty for failing forbidden melds, I guess it makes sense to just plug along with low level materia to get those extra +3 INT... until you get lucky. That is probably more useful than trying to get a third G5 materia of the 6th most useful stat to stick. Not even sure I could think of a 6th particularly worthwhile stat category for BLM for example, not worth throwing G5 materia at any rate.

---

TBH, I'd put the highest grade materia in there first because the success rate is higher, then cap out the base stats with the cheap stuff last.

I seriously can't wait for phase 4, materia is like gamers crack to me, I love the concept so much. :)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Molly_Millions

TBH, I'd put the highest grade materia in there first because the success rate is higher, then cap out the base stats with the cheap stuff last.

I seriously can't wait for phase 4, materia is like gamers crack to me, I love the concept so much. :)

---

Right, that's what I meant. I know what you mean, I really like the materia system as well. I just hope we can make endgame relevant gear and weapons that way even if it isn't BiS.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Cynthis

Right, that's what I meant. I know what you mean, I really like the materia system as well. I just hope we can make endgame relevant gear and weapons that way even if it isn't BiS.

---

Currently we can make relevant armor, but weapons, not so much.