which weapon?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by AmyNeudaiz

+30 STR > +30 Attack Power
If you +1 a Cobalt Guisarme with 2 grade IV materia that is plenty stronger than Ifrit's Harpoon.

---

Amy i have come to the conclusion that you arent a very intelligent person so im not gonna even get into details as to why ifrits is better.

Sorry, but Ifrit's is better, and not just because of "str vs. attack".

Holy shit since when did people who think something else is better incite so much hatred?





























Oh wait this is the FFXIV forum. Instead of ad hominem attacks on my IQ why don't you come back with a better reason than "because I said you're stupid". Until then, have fun.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by AmyNeudaiz

Holy shit since when did people who think something else is better incite so much hatred?





























Oh wait this is the FFXIV forum. Instead of ad hominem attacks on my IQ why don't you come back with a better reason than "because I said you're stupid". Until then, have fun.

---

whats the point? you prolly wouldnt get it anyways lol

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Malix

whats the point? you prolly wouldnt get it anyways lol

---

Oh, I see. You don't have any facts you're gonna avoid trying to prove your case.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by AmyNeudaiz

Oh, I see. You don't have any facts you're gonna avoid trying to prove your case.

---

Someone already tried pointing facts out with what the DPS and Damage done compared to both are and you still didn't listen. What else do you want, "Pie * x + ahghahar * argarearvarv = blah blah"? Like wtf, really?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Eliseus

Someone already tried pointing facts out with what the DPS and Damage done compared to both are and you still didn't listen. What else do you want, "Pie * x + ahghahar * argarearvarv = blah blah"? Like wtf, really?

---

Holy shi... and you people call me stupid. Auto attack damage is not comparable to weapon skill damage, period. STR increases your WS damage by a considerable amount while damage adds to your auto attack damage how are you not getting this? If you pick which weapon alone is stronger then the winner goes to the +1 crafted with decent double STR materia.

As far as my other post about Pie vs Crit Attack that was already covered earlier in this thread.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by AmyNeudaiz

Holy shi... and you people call me stupid. Auto attack damage is not comparable to weapon skill damage, period. STR increases your WS damage by a considerable amount while damage adds to your auto attack damage how are you not getting this? If you pick which weapon alone is stronger then the winner goes to the +1 crafted with decent double STR materia.

As far as my other post about Pie vs Crit Attack that was already covered earlier in this thread.

---

http://forum.square-enix.com/ffxiv/t...IE-ATK-Testing

Read later in the thread about testing on damage and dps of a weapon etc.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Eliseus

http://forum.square-enix.com/ffxiv/t...IE-ATK-Testing

Read later in the thread about testing on damage and dps of a weapon etc.

---

Oh man those Garuda weapons. Suck low base damage must really hurt your stat caps. They are terrible aren't they?
/sarcasm
There could in all honesty just be a flaw in his formula. I haven't looked at that post since he first made it and his sample size was pretty small. I wouldn't really take that thread as solid fact unless it's been peer reviewed or cross referenced.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Eliseus

Please never play Dragoon again, I even waited all day to post too see if idiots like you would stop posting such false information. Do us all a favor and go away and don't post on the dragoon forums again, because you are wrong.

---

even if she is wrong in this case, do you just sit on this board all day looking for people you think are wrong then patronizing them?