Fascination with Isghard: Why do we want it?
Because that stupid motherf*cker at the gate told us we're not allowed in.
Seriously, that's about it for most of us. That uppity, zealous d-nozzle is denying me my rightful entry to content.
Fascination with Isghard: Why does the OP want it?
Because I formed an irrational bond with the 2005 promo movie and I cling like ivy to the idea that we might still see a city that looks even remotely as interesting. So I agree with you - flesh out our cities. If you read back through my musings on Ishgard (especially my "commemorative landmark" one) you'll find that I don't really want Ishgard, I just want them to bring back the idea of having an area driven aesthetically entirely on wrought iron, potted flora, and tiles of glass and stone. I don't really care what else there is. I guess there'll be an aether and an AG and some quests, shops, and a chocobo guy... but whatever. Screw all that.
Three words: Wrought. Iron. Everything.
http://www.ffxivvault.com/gallery/im...1&image_id=189
http://i1188.photobucket.com/albums/...ak/Rapture.jpg
Mmmmmmmm.