Would you run daily challenge dungeons?

no I already have to deal with people that cant heal or cant tank and still dont know thier rotations at max level why would I put myself through that?

Maybe instead of unique gear, maybe dyeable or alternate colors of the gear that already drops in the dungeon. Or maybe the gear can just be glamourable by all classes like the Eureka stuff.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ForteNightshade

Except Yoshida answered it seemingly under the assumption they would have to make brand new "EX" dungeons. The OP is literally copy/pasting systems already in the game. If they went this direction, it takes minimal work and gives people more to do on a given week. Not to mention, it also lets the dev team gauge potential interest if it's worth expanding on in the future.

---

It's still work they don't want to assign to anyone to take away from their already full schedule.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Kaethra

"I don't like it so you can't have it."

This attitude needs to be routed out.

---

so basically anyone who disagrees with you doesn't get to voice their opinion either?

Quote:

---

"I don't like it so you can't have it."

This attitude needs to be routed out.

---

Except that wasn't even what the person you were quoting was saying?

The topic is asking if we would run the content if such a thing existed in the game, to which "absolutely not" is a perfectly valid response. Dunno where you're getting this "I don't like it so nobody should have it" thing from.

Pick up PotD floor 180+ and HoH floor 80+ enemies and place them in dungeons as the "trash".
And add permanent Gloom for good measure.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Kaethra

"I don't like it so you can't have it."

This attitude needs to be routed out.

---

Normally, I would agree, but Yoshida himself has said if they were to work on something new, they would have to sacrifice on something else. So at least for this game, it is absolutely necessary for each player to support what they support and to be against what they have no interest in doing unless they could be assured it would not impact their choice of activity negatively.

Honestly, if it was as the OP suggested, only for fun if my friends and FC wanted to run it. Otherwise I wouldn't bother.

Being a max level Omnicrafter who does the Hunt, I don't have any need for Expert Roulette. I have tomes by the thousands, decent gear, enough gil to buy all the minions and music. Even dungeon gear with 5 slots has no use to me. Materia is poured out in hundreds from Eureka too.

Something unique would get my interest though. For example a rare mount or exclusive shiny glamour for completing every "Challenge" dungeon.

If they added something like it, I might give it a try.

Would I do them actively would depend mostly on if they're actually worth doing and can reliably be done with PUGs.

I burnt myself out from Mythics back in Legion so i'm not really sure. Unless there's some glamours or if my friends drag me to it, these things are always more fun with friends.