Seems ok actually, tank secondaries don't matter much outside of progression anyways and pvp gear matches pve gear in terms of primary stats. The healers should have been able to keep him alive in their sleep.
Of course if he was a crap tank......I can recall one tank pulling caduceus with provoke, and claiming the reason he couldn't hold agro was because his ilvl 110 weap couldn't hold up against a 115 nexus. The blm ripped agro with his opening thunder II xD
inb4 white knights: Yes, we did teach him how to tank xD
