Market board - forced to buy an item on the board while not at the market board

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Sagimoto

Those that this unforunate event happened to. Can you please describe how, and where it happened? More imporantly was the gil on your person when this happened? or was gil pulled from your retainer too? Much appreciated.

---

The gil was on my character when it happened. Happened at Limsa Lominsa Lower Decks - Hawker Alley. My retainers were unaffected.

Here's my screenshots. (I'm the person in post #12)

Here I am, trying to run to my retainer to save my remaining gil. (And you can see the "Insufficient Gil" message on top)
http://i.imgur.com/rxAKXYv.jpg

Here's the history I saw after trying to save remaining gil. Couldn't find the retainer who sold the Antidote but I found the retainer selling the Allagan Tin pieces.
http://i.imgur.com/zcKsXkU.jpg
http://i.imgur.com/niRDA5v.jpg

I sent in-game reports / gm-calls and there have been no responses so far. I can send them the original screenshots with chat (timestamps included) from the time I logged in. I was actually busy melding the gear I was supposed to spiritbond while chatting with friend so I didn't notice the purchase message. Only noticed its when I opened my inventory and saw the Allagan tin piece go in I immediately looked at my gil and was like ... !@#$@ .

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Carrisa

I don't think it is an issue with with GSM. Anybody will be a potential victim.

I have came up with a theory. I think potentially it would be a case of packet editing.

---

My theory is packet sniffing for Buyer IDs and other details, followed by Buyer ID spoofing for the sales. Limsa seems to be the main target for this, simply because the Aetherye being in the same zone as the Market Board provides a large amount of traffic that can be caught.

Not trying to be smart or something, but i think this exploit happened due to the way the packet sent to the server is structured.

A packet to purchase an item off the board could contain the following
- Buyer ID
- Seller ID
- Item ID

If the hacker could edit the data within the Buyer ID before sending it to the server, I think the server would perceive it as the victim himself who sent the packet to the server to purchase the items instead. Hence, the player purchased the items automatically without even being near the market board.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MarshMallows

History and search result for Allagan Tin..
It might help. People from my server (tonberry) were also affected.

Looks like the player with a retainer named Dsgds was one of the culprit.


http://i42.tinypic.com/15ovx5j.png

---

I can confirm too! As you can see my name was the first forcedbuying tin piece.

Wtf is going on? This is madness!

Login to share my experience.
Insufficient Gil keeps appearing on my screen while I am crafting near the "Market board". It happened maybe 2 hrs before.
Luckily that.. I have all my gil on retainers

this just happened to me as well, was chatting with a friend in limsa while crafting

Time: Between 11:00 - 11:39 am (PST)

Frequency: Once

World name: Behemoth

Character name: Cass Tristesse

NPC name: Market Board

Area and coordinates: Limsa Lominsa Lower Decks 12x 13y

Steps:
1. was crafting some armorsmith, then a friend came by and we chatted
2. during the conversation was seeing "insufficient gil" msg on my screen, didnt know what it was
3. went to summoner's bell to get some materials to make some stuff for my friend
4. then went back and got this msg that i bought a braised pipira
5. looked at the market board and saw my history that i bought it for 1 million gil =(, I was nowhere near the marketboard.

Goal: hopefully to recover my lost 1 million gil

http://i.imgur.com/aaTZsVD.jpg

http://i.imgur.com/yZ1ayy5.jpg

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Carrisa

Not trying to be smart or something, but i think this exploit happened due to the way the packet sent to the server is structured.

A packet to purchase an item off the board could contain the following
- Buyer ID
- Seller ID
- Item ID

If the hacker could edit the data within the Buyer ID before sending it to the server, I think the server would perceive it as the victim himself who sent the packet to the server to purchase the items instead. Hence, the player purchased the items automatically without even being near the market board.

---

However, if my theory is right, then nobody is safe in the server as long as the hacker has your ID. Logging out would be the safest option.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Carrisa

The gil was on my character when it happened. Happened at Limsa Lominsa Lower Decks - Hawker Alley. My retainers were unaffected.

---

Thank you for the response, hopefully people's gil on retainers will stay safe.