Consolidated White Mage 4.0 Feedback Thread

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Cyrocco

Has White Mage ever traditionally been a nature based job though? I don't believe previous games had White Mages leaning towards either nature or the church-type though. Hopefully we can chalk it up to spells learned from someone who originates from Ishgard? They're big on churches.

---

Geomancer and White Mage have always been separate jobs. Although White Mage most of the time had Aero and Tornado magic.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Exiled_Tonberry

It really really sucks. Remember Y'shtola's ultimate move. That spell that looked like it combined all the elements for one massive attack. I wanted something like that.
But SE is hung up on giving us nothing but heals and the occasional stone spell. Sigh. Would have loved to see amazing spells like Tornado and Quake.

---

Ironic that a Conjurer can use a far more impressive spell than us White Mages. I also wanted something like that spell the minute I saw it. Instead we get a slightly different looking version of Tetra for our cap Ability...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Exiled_Tonberry

WHM doesn't have anything in it's entire toolkit that feels truly powerful or borderline broken.

---

Benediction ?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Ceasaria

Benediction ?

---

It feels clunky, at best.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Ceasaria

Benediction ?

---

Benediction heals to full HP, putting it anywhere between:"Less useful than a regen" to "Slightly better than Essential Dignity" depending on where the HP currently stand.

It would be an exceptionally powerful spell... if healers couldn't heal for 20%++ of even a tank's maximum HP non-crit with a regular GCD ability. The best part of it is that it ignores Cleric Stance... which is going the way of the Dodo soon.

Visually it's not all that impressive either - I often mistake it for Tetra >.>

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Ceasaria

Benediction ?

---

A single target full heal is so unimpressive at this stage of the game.
It can't even go through Cleric Stance anymore, which is all it had going for it in HW.
Not to mention it has awful delay for an insta heal. Not sure why it's not fixed yet honestly.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by AlphaSonic

Although White Mage most of the time had Aero and Tornado magic.

---

Uuuh. No, that's not true at all. Its very rare for White Mages to have attack spells outside Holy or summons. Also, wind magic is rare in general for FF.

I have always loved WHM. I was actually quite happy with the changes until I saw scholar was given the 20% crit utility. It can be tough thinking up what kind of utility WHM should get that won't make it too overpowered. This one suggestion might be a decent one.

- 'Raise' with 3 Lillies sacrifices the lillies and restores target to full health with no Weakness.

It may not be a full party bonus, but a target not having weakness can help boost damage even for a little.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Ceasaria

Benediction ?

---

You mean the ability that most often than not kills the target because it doesn't go off and you end up using on yourself? Yeah, it's great.

I do have to say the ONLY thing I'm actually looking forward to is no more CS. I've had more times of it not turning off or it not turning on in the pass couple days, leading to almost deaths, than I care to admit. I really won't miss it.

So give Benediction to SCH then, because according to you, it's not a loss for WHM.