Pld buff or War nerf in 1.22?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SwordCoheir

Follow up... to the majority of Aces posts.

To Ace:

I just want to point out, you've been very contradicting about your arguments that PLD isn't broken and your capabilities. You've stated alot of "why bother documenting or show you guys anything you wont believe me," yet many have posted documented evidence that's backed up by a majority of the community contradicting your claims, yet you outright dispute it without proof of your own.

The only thing I could truly agree on with you is IT DOES function as intended, but it's only strength which is defense is severely lacking. The rest of what you say really make's it hard to accept you have any concept of how the game mechanics truly work other than you just saying that "I'm right and your wrong you stupid n00b."

---

Oh, but don't forget his epic parser posts where he shows the damage he takes. That's TOTALLY conclusive.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Aceofspades

they prolly woulda left WAR alone if people could learn to NOT bitch about PLD, I was happy whith where everthing was, PLD was great for saftey runs and WAR was great for crowd controll / speed runs. How this adjustment will effect the status quoe is yet to be seen but lets hope all those love drunk WARs out there kept their REAL tanking gear, you know the stuff with DEF/VIT/and HP....

---

eh..people have been bitching about Pld since ffxi. Plds will always bitch if they're not made the best tanks evar in the game.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Searious

eh..people have been bitching about Pld since ffxi. Plds will always bitch if they're not made the best tanks evar in the game.

---

...that's kinda their reason for existence.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Searious

eh..people have been bitching about Pld since ffxi. Plds will always bitch if they're not made the best tanks evar in the game.

---

Isn't that the point of our existence?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Vanguard319

that makes no sense, between af and available gear, pld should have no equal in enmity gain.

---

Started off as my only job as PLD. Tanked Ifrit people beat it however people did have to hold back on damage. I leveled WAR because they were out tanking PLD so badly on everything. I tanked Ifrit again and nobody even came close to pulling him off and they can go all out. Mainly due to the fact that so much enmity in this game is generated by damage.

I would like to tank on PLD again when they fix it.

WAR nerf, huh? I really want to be upset about that, but it is needed.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Amherst

WAR nerf, huh? I really want to be upset about that, but it is needed.

---

Not even a nerf really, they're toning down one AoE and upping another and making Berserk more attractive to use. Collusion is useful but not necessary really, so whatever they do to it probably won't affect WAR enough to really make much difference. Course it might be different if Yoshi changes more than he said.

/sarcasm on
PLD can't hold threat? Nerf WAR!
/sarcasm off

All PLD needs is more HP and an AOE WS, granted you won't be doing the same damage as a WAR can but that's the point.. One is a healing tank, the other is a damaging tank.. No need to nerf Steel Cyclone and adjust Collusion.

great, they are over nerf war. great. at least I have blm leveled. they never nerf blm.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Majidah

great, they are over nerf war. great. at least I have blm leveled. they never nerf blm.

---

lolwut????