Puzzles?!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Tonkra

well ok you are right. but on the other hand i dont like the idea of mixing up crafting classes with combat.i only would like that in pvp maybe, where crafters can create siege weapons and so on, and special ammunition.

but as for the classic combats.. i dont like the idea of mixing up crafter and fighter classes. well thats just my taste.. so..


for me a battle is a battle and not a place to craft.

i'd like that aspect in a pure adventure game like Broken Sword.. but not for final fantasy rpg.

---

<<this, for most part i'd like to see crafts separate even from hamlets and also keep puzzles seperate, even the cut scenes prior to a battle that involves a party should be b4 the fight for a solo person to see without others having to wait for others to watch it or to be forced to skip it.

All they have to do is make CS's like FFXI, throw you into the CS let everyone watch it, proceed to the battlefield AFTER the cutscene...as in you select the entrance twice or the timer doesn't begin until you engage the monster and if someone leeroys their way to defeat victory it's their own fault :D

The only reason people were skipping was due to the idiotic speedrun requirements to see any decent gear drops in a dungeon.

In the blog post, Yoshi has what looks like a map of the dungeon in front of him. I've been trying to enhance it in photo-shop, but the resolution is too low to really make out much, drat it.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Skullmaker

In the blog post, Yoshi has what looks like a map of the dungeon in front of him. I've been trying to enhance it in photo-shop, but the resolution is too low to really make out much, drat it.

---

hm what i didnt mention yet.. looks like we get finally an outdoor (or partly outdoor) dungeon now (woo*) this is so great..

because i hated that we only had caves in 1.0... you can do just so much more than just caves.
well maybe i was not the only who made suggestions long time ago about "puzzles/riddles" and outdoor dungeons.. well i should become a game designer ^^

these ruins remind me a bit of Final Fantasy 12... but well you actually cant see much.

Who said jumping puzzle!?

I have mixed feelings about puzzles. On one hand I love them! On the other if it is in content that you do repeatedly, the charm of solving a puzzle is lost because once it's solved you know the answer.

Now unless the puzzle has a randomly generated solution will it remain challenging. I loved CC "initially" for it's uniqueness in progressing through the dungeon. But you do it half a dozen times and it loses it's charm.

And like some said before puzzles in large groups is a nightmare! Somebody always drops the ball or doesn't care, and while this does happen in small groups, in large ones you rage out of frustration because 5 ppl keep slacking when you only have to deal with 1 in a small party.

Easy puzzles are cool when the hints are easy to find. And as long as the hints to the solution change with the randomly generated answer it should be fine!

Riddles, probably should stay with solo content. However getting ppl to work together to solve riddles can be fun.

I feel like, at this point in 2.0 development, they could show us potato salad and half of us would love it, half of us would hate it, and 2 or 3 of us would be saying we should wait and see what its like first before judging. Beta and release can not come soon enough for this galka. Not trying to hate, just tired of teasers and ready for the game already :p

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Cedri

Not jumping puzzles... Please... anything but jumping puzzles...

---

Jumping puzzles, yes please!
Puzzles with multiple routes, with jumping and without jumping (to stop the whiners), yes please!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Nakiamiie

Jumping puzzles, yes please!
Puzzles with multiple routes, with jumping and without jumping (to stop the whiners), yes please!

---

http://24.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_mc...4o4_r2_250.gif