Is it possible to create a 100% male guild ?

Think my favorite thing about these kinds of threads is that the first 1-2 pages is always like "HAH!! BAAAAAAIT" and then it hits 10+ pages with like philosophical debates and stuff about all kinds of things that no one actually cares about because nothing that any of you says is going to make anyone here think differently than they already do for even a fraction of a second. Their minds are already made up in what they believe no matter how stupid or blatantly untrue it is, so then it just becomes a battle of which side is either getting the most pats or which side is more "morally/politically" correct.

Anyway, you can absolutely have this FC! You can literally have any FC you want. No matter who screams and cries about not being let in. Generally nobody cares about FCs-not until someone says 'you cant join' anyway, then suddenly everyones posting their life story and self discovery struggle like anyone cares which they dont. If you want to avoid trouble I guess don't advertise it but. You can still have it. Just talk to people and recruit only those that you see fit and don't let them for any reason sneak in someone who doesnt fit. Anyone upset can also make their own FC.

I'm calling bull on this because I have joined male only linkshells and fellowships that are explicitly state to be non-romantic dudes hanging out spaces and have not heard a peep about these groups getting banned for being male only, I'm agreeing with the others that you probably had some homophobic drivel in the description that ACTUALLY got you banned.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Breakbeat

I hate to break it to you, but true equality went out the window right around the time social media reared its ugly head. We aren't interested in treating each human as a human regardless of their color or gender or religion or sexuality, and we aren't interested in any segregated group being 100% of anything unless it's a minority or a sexual orientation other than straight.

Literally. We used to say back in the '90s, "be color blind," and people were actually going with it. Now our race and gender and sexuality need to be worn on our sleeves, all of that stuff comes before actually just being a human. We're deeper into this nonsense than we were 20 years ago.

---

Of all the posts yours is the most truthful of them all. I am not a fan of people that feel the need to push their views on people,that they are (insert race) or have to constantly talk about their preferences. If you want to be treated the same as everyone then don't seek for attention all the time. That just makes people feel deterred more then helps. Just live your life, don’t make it a spectacle.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Zomkei

if you're willing to explain, i am actually curious on why you take this approach. do you allow women and nonbinary people with male characters join, or do you make sure they're all men irl too? no hate, i am just curious on why.

---

I don’t know him, so I only speak for myself

I’ve been a member of such communities before. We don’t hate women nor femininity. We’re just there to speak whatever we want in whatever way we like without the risk of offending women.

Sometimes we just like to talk shit to each other, but we can’t do that in front of women

See, it's bait threads like this, that just create even more strife between the different classes of people who play this game.

Now, I understand if some of this is, "Truthful." Because I do see FC's recruiting who mention they are, mostly female or mostly LGBTQA+, but no where do they say, "You HAVE to be one of these to join." Obviously a guy could join the mostly female FC, as long as they're not a dog and think they're going to be in some sort of harem scenerio, like an anime... or when joining a LGBTQA+ FC, as long as you're not there to poke fun or be otherwise ignorant, then you should be fine.

In the end, this thread's topic, sounds very much like troll bait, posted by someone who knows how ridiculous they are being, in an attempt to get people riled up.

*Side Note* I am willing to bet you got Banned on your farm account, due to the use of certain, against ToS, 3rd party programs... But I could be wrong.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by HolyReign

Because I do see FC's recruiting who mention they are, mostly female or mostly LGBTQA+, but no where do they say, "You HAVE to be one of these to join."

---

https://forum.square-enix.com/ffxiv/...discord-server

there you go, its right here on the forums, dont even need to go far.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by HanWenqing

I don't have any problem to play with female players since ff14 is casual.

---

Pretty sure this attitude has explained the whole story of why you were banned. Whenever I see guys in gaming say this type of thing I laugh because I'm a woman that's probably raided in MMOs longer than they've been alive.

As for making an FC for men and you don't have this kind of attitude towards women? I don't think anyone would care. I have a few guy friends that are in CWLS or FCs that are specifically for LGBT men. I'm not at all offended that they're in those CWLS/FCs as I know their intent isn't "women suck at this game so I'm not going to play with them". If my guy friends want a space to talk about guy stuff it doesn't bother me as I know it's not because they see me as lesser. I don't think they care that I go to my girl friends for specific discussions either.

You can if you want. Just don't run around being misogynistic.

Ugh, I don't know why this thread even exists but yes to answer the OP's query of course you can create a FC of all men. Know however that the premise alone is likely gonna scare more than a few potential recruits off due to the most likely motive of desiring such a FC in the first place. I just hope you came here for guidance, and not validation because if so you won't find it here.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Bukachu

https://forum.square-enix.com/ffxiv/...discord-server

there you go, its right here on the forums, dont even need to go far.

---

Oh man I remember that. As a joke I made a men only discord post as a joke. I was temp banned for 10 days. Good times.

Well there's already too much FC with catgrills only or potatoes only so making all men or all Hrothgar are valid IMO :)

He's coming back!

https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachmen...et-awkward.gif

EDIT: With extra misogynist as well :eek:

SentioftheHoukai

Take this in the spirit its meant but...can i come to your server and hug the stuffing out of you? ;););)

LOl

You need to buy her a Crockpot they are amazing...I just give mine a stir every few hours and game all day long why my man is out hunting and keeping me in the luxury I am used too :)

Joking aside I am female and old and have gamed most of my life and I am not casual in any game. You will also note that because I gamed my Daughter now is a lead artist in a games company! They employ females now :O

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by HanWenqing

Literally every single word this person has said in this thread

---

Thank you so much, it's been so long since I saw this level of awkwardness :,,D

P.S:
The person hard-carrying me through content and teaching me how to play properly is a woman.

With love
- a man who's confident enough not to feel like he has to use expressions like "beta male"

I love checking back on this thread and I'm just now thinking. How has this not been put into the dumpster fire by the mods already?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Atelier-Bagur

I love checking back on this thread and I'm just now thinking. How has this not been put into the dumpster fire by the mods already?

---

At this point Im convinced they just abandoned the english forum section entirely.

It’s probably better that way lol

Log shaming? Really?

Liam, to be honest....you are better than this. And in doing so you just proved my point about how logs can be misused. Mate..IMO, take the link out.

It really doesnt help.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by VelKallor

Log shaming? Really?

Liam, to be honest....you are better than this. And in doing so you just proved my point about how logs can be misused. Mate..IMO, take the link out.

It really doesnt help.

---

Nah nah, let this one slide. OP hasn't made any friends with how he wants to label/view women in this game/in life... so personally I think all common courtesy is out the window already.

If someone is boasting about how they'd destroy everyone with their superior gameplay and stating that women are only in hardcore content because they're the concubine of a man, I consider it perfectly fine to just drop a link. Because the person making such claims can better back them up.
Turns out they can't, to everyone's surprise no doubt.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Rilifane

If someone is boasting about how they'd destroy everyone with their superior gameplay and stating that women are only in hardcore content because they're the concubine of a man, I consider it perfectly fine to just drop a link. Because the person making such claims can better back them up.
Turns out they can't, to everyone's surprise no doubt.

---

Would probably make OP break out in a sweat if they knew the # of women that I do that raid alone/without their partner for current savage. Hell, I'm in a majority female static for syncd min ilvl no echo ARR-EW trials/normal raids, we're heading into Coils after we wrap up Ifrit this week.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Atelier-Bagur

I love checking back on this thread and I'm just now thinking. How has this not been put into the dumpster fire by the mods already?

---

Give it a month at least lol

I just want to see the OP dig himself deeper into this misogynistic hole he's dug himself into. I find it highly amusing as a woman.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Atelier-Bagur

I love checking back on this thread and I'm just now thinking. How has this not been put into the dumpster fire by the mods already?

---

They're probably sitting there with a bag of popcorn and enjoying the show.
I know I would.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by LianaThorne

Nah nah, let this one slide. OP hasn't made any friends with how he wants to label/view women in this game/in life... so personally I think all common courtesy is out the window already.

---

Liana, normally Id stick to my guns..but in this case:

*bows gallantly*

I concede to your judgement, m'lady.
































...WHAT? Cant I be a gentleman once in a while?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Atelier-Bagur

I love checking back on this thread and I'm just now thinking. How has this not been put into the dumpster fire by the mods already?

---

i dont think mods exist. and if they do they dare not venture into the cesspool that is general discussion

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Lihtleita

i dont think mods exist. and if they do they dare not venture into the cesspool that is general discussion

---

They do if you report someone, or if enough people report someone for being... well. Like OP.

(Psst. Square-Enix. I modded/admin'd forums for many years, you can hire me, I can deal with things here, promise. Gen Disc doesn't scare me.)

From what I've read, a woman who "knows her place" knows that she belongs at a legally enforced minimum 50m distance from OP.

There's nothing wrong with a woman wanting to be a housewife, wanting a man who's the "breadwinner" and such.
It becomes a problem when you want it to be an enfirced standard and belittle those who think differently.

I am sincerely hoping and mostly believing that this is all satire, and that OP's wife is make-believe.
But there's this little voice whispering: "maybe..."

Also, lol @ the notion of proving any kind of "gaming skill" through FF's PvP system.

the 14th century called... they would like their thread back

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Kes13a

the 14th century called... they would like their thread back

---

Sis, this is the 21st century, we have a kids fantasy author whining about cis women-only spaces.

OP please get therapy. Please. This isn't healthy. You attitude towards women is very concerning. You clearly have some issues you are not acknowledging. I beg you to seek a therapist out. Your life will get so much better, trust me.

https://i.ytimg.com/vi/vEqeyZlKAnI/maxresdefault.jpg

I am giggling at everything in this thread. How is it seriously so hard for people to tell when they're being teased and trolled? My goodness. It's like the internet is brand new to some. (The trolling is hilarious, by the way.)

I don't think this guy is a troll.

Judging by his posted logs and his opinions in this thread, and who he seems to aspire to, he's a braindead idiot.

We need to stop treating these people as trolls and humouring them. He needs to be on some sort of watchlist.

This guy and his opinions are dangerous, and he needs to be behind bars or under supervision before he ends up hurting someone, assuming he hasn't already.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Arrhin

Been watching this thread alternating between gut wrenching laughter (at you) and horror (also you). Serious question tho, as you seem to be one of those "I get the last word so that makes me right" kinda people....is THIS your last post? Or will there be one more, and then one more...erm..."last post". ...

---

I wish this topic would sink or a gm would delete it because it's starting to wear me out.
I don't feel like posting on it anymore but when someone spits on me or threatens me I feel obliged to answer and correct the false statements they throw in my face...

Me be like:
(First saw this thread coming up in the first page few days ago and thinking that it might just die... and I'm proven wrong... let's see what's in he--)
https://c.tenor.com/RVvOkiUabtkAAAAC...-community.gif

Carry on, ladies & gentlemen...

10 days clearly wasnt enough to change anything.

1v1 me Han. I want to kick that ass to the point it will finally stop talking.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SassyAssassin

1v1 me Han. I want to kick that ass to the point it will finally stop talking.

---

if you do, make sure to record it, add in some heavy metal and have it set on Azim Steppe.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SassyAssassin

1v1 me Han. I want to kick that ass to the point it will finally stop talking.

---

Okay, but you have to come to my world for the fight.
You can bet between 10 000 000 gils and 50 000 000 gils

You will have to give me the amount you bet and if you win I will give you what you gave me x2 but if I win I keep the gils.

There will be only 1 fight.

It would be nice indeed if you filmed and I hope you will post the video even if you lose

Of course it's obvious that you will lose, but if you accept the rules we'll do it whenever you want.

I'm even willing to apologize for anything and everything and become a beta if I lose

It's up to you now if you want to taste the ground you know what you have to do.