[Suggestion] Trial of the Magians

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Kyata

*snip*

---

You honestly don't get it, people hated TotM, it's not because it's FFXI it's because people don't want to be forced to kill 2000 crabs for a small upgrade, then Impulse Drive 5000 times and finally for the meaningful upgrade hit 5000 Chaos Thrust combos, that is not hard work it's just tedium. The only way FFXI managed to get people to do these is because they had to for decent gear, if they added more drops to Limbus for example that were equal to TotM gear, even with a low drop rate people would have gone with that over TotM any day.

Trial Moogle: Sure, I'll upgrade your weapon for you! Just bring me 1500 Heavy Metal Plates!
Me: *Slugs moogle IN THE FACE.*

*sigh* If only that was really an option...

Yes please i really never liked to ws stuff but at least myself grow bored of the game and i need something to do besides myth stuff coils and primals lol
Bring back ny old grinding xD

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Kyata

The premature bias is amazing, no one's even looking at my post or noticing that I mentioned it would have to be "tweaked to fit FFXIV and its playerbase"

---

That has already been done as many people have pointed out. It's really just saying that it isn't like FFXI enough, and many people consider that a plus.

Quote:

---

I don't know about everyone else, but I like to get my rewards after hard work, so I can feel like I accomplished something worthwhile. I can count the amount of times I, or anyone on my vent channel yelled out in joy for something we did or received on one hand.

---

I do that too it's called downing Twintania. Progression groups is where you get your feeling of accomplishment, and I'd prefer it in challenging content rather than a tedious grind.

I liked upgrading some silly melded weapon into a Relic.

And I liked upgrading my silly Relic into a Relic Zenith.

I'll probably like upgrading my silly Relic Zenith into something even better.


Do I want to do it the same way as FFXI decided to do it?









Probably not.

NO THANKS still have nightmares

the idea was cool , but so poorly implemented....well its FFXI .....we couldnt expect anything less than that

this suggestion implies SE will introduce fun stats on weapons.... wont happen any time soon..

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Kimikryo

Red Mage? sure sounds like Red Mage.

---

LOL yes...it was on Red Mage, i think it took me 6 tries before i beat it....was so horrible. ; ;

I'm for it..... Long as I don't have to camp NMs, get 1500 HMPs, and 200 Riftcinder to make another 99 Almace I'm ok with them adding ToM type content to FFXIV.

ToM just wasn't about weapons it was for Relic Gear and AF3. OP is right if we had content like this it would be nice. I would rather go kill 10k mobs than to finish up current content for the week and have nothing else to do.

Sounds like an awesome idea, better than anything we have now, which is lockouts,play 2 days out of the week and be done with the game until the next week.

I don't get people who are against this, they say it would be very tedious, as if battling RNG in coil isn't? At-least with a system that the OP mentioned, we'll actually have some other form of progression that actually gives us reason to log in more than 2 days out of the week.

you are either crazy or just have too much free time........either way, i dont agree with this

me personally, i liked the toughness of ffxi, not the time sink........and hope they come out with some challenging fun content. personally, my favorite was nyzul isle, except doing 100 floors of it, maybe 20-40 and up the difficulty some=

Aside from some very questionable NM choices (Black Triple Stars? Really?) and some lack of foresight (infrequency of hot spells) the initial rollout of TotM (weapons) wasn't entirely bad. The idea of building a weapon was a decent way for players to avoid the drama of HNMs and NM claiming. Turning it into a slog in Abyssea to massage the egos of people who had Relic and Mythic weapons was a gigantic mistake, however, and the devs only compounded their mistakes since that point with Geode and Avatarite trials.

I wouldn't mind an adaptation of it in XIV (a tie-in with the Mogglesguard would not be a great stretch, if you think about it) if the targets, quotas, and conditions were reasonable (5 Ifrit/Garuda/Titan HM clears each, for example, isn't too much to ask depending on the iLv. of the base weapon. 10 EX clears each would veer way too close to the Tanaka zone for my liking).

They'd probably just make every trial to do 250 FATEs each >.>

Didn't much care for the system in FFXI and don't much care for the idea of it in FFXIV. I'd rather have BCNMs back in the form of guildhests that drop loot or something.

Come on Matt Red Mage Fight for all..... Everyone should have to endure those loving moments...lol I don't mind it later in game but I do agree I don't want to have to do something 3k time on a certain day when there fog and fight this MoB

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Navycrow

Come on Matt Red Mage Fight for all..... Everyone should have to endure those loving moments...lol

---

Omg you are so evil XD i don't want to experience Matt Red Mage fight ever again, PC peripherals cost too much these days to replace when you destroy them out of anger and frustration. ; ;

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by warren-ragnarok

you are either crazy or just have too much free time........either way, i dont agree with this

me personally, i liked the toughness of ffxi, not the time sink........and hope they come out with some challenging fun content. personally, my favorite was nyzul isle, except doing 100 floors of it, maybe 20-40 and up the difficulty some=

---

Now you know what, I will admit I miss Nyzul Isle. Well, except the lamps. But I always like dungeon crawler games and that place definitely scratched that itch.