Another issue here is half of us are going to be talking about the story and half of us are going to be talking about mechanical/content changes.
The content has always been mostly the same formula just occasionally trying a new thing like they did with variant/criterion dungeons in EW, the Firmament/Ocean Fishing in ShB and Ultimates in SB, so I feel like it comes down to whether the aesthetics/story is hype enough and that's why my arguments are centered around it.
