FFVIII was the biggest single letdown I have ever had in a video game, just surpassing Chrono Cross. Wooden characters (including the single worst individual in a FF game: Rinoa), a difficult-to-follow, disjointed plot rife with long flashbacks and sudden, inexplicable tonal shifts, the outright, unambiguously bad junction system that ruined magic, and an antagonist that - while she possesses people - doesn't actually show herself until the very end of the game, together make for what is easily the worst main-series Final Fantasy game (and this is including complete garbage like XII and X [and X-2, if it counts]). This anthology has given me some of my highest highs as a gamer... but it has also offered distinct, brutal lows, and FFVIII will always hold that nadir in my heart.
To be honest, I'm not convinced that they can ever create a satisfactory stand-alone Final Fantasy again. XIII wasn't a good game, and neither was XV. The FFVII remake has been really engaging (although it has me worried - I don't ship Aerith/Zack, and am enormously concerned that the reintroduction of Zack will make for a third wheel) so far, but it's built on a pretty solid nostalgic foundation, and would have been difficult to miss with. I dunno... I don't have high expectations for the eventual FFXVI, although at least it appears to be set in a semi-traditional fantasy world, so that's a minor plus.
