It honestly sounds like all the people against this are ones who don't actually make an active effort to spawn the hunts in the first place...so I'm not sure why you'd advocate for things remaining as random and unpredictable as they are currently when it would have basically no bearing on how you go about hunting and only benefit those who do take the hunts seriously.
I enjoy spawning/sharing the S ranks with people, but I've long since stopped making a big deal about those who actively attempt to prevent that from happening because they like the negative attention.