Well I just lots a ton of respect for Jared.
The biggest issue of course being that even if you count it separately from 1.0, ARR is a 2012 game.
If you're stretching the rules that much you should probably give that slot to Chrono Trigger or FF VI.
And of course the other issue that the only thing XIV is "best" at is being a WoW clone. "Least sucky WoW clone on the market" could be their slogan. Doesn't change the fact that there has never been a good WoW clone.
