Lack of Potions, Ethers, and other item usage

Do you think it would cause too many troubles if potions recovered a certain percentage of HP instead of a set amount? Normal is 20%, +1 is 25%, and so on.

Would spamming potions become an issue? If so, then perhaps quaffing a potion could have short cooldown timer, around 10 seconds of so.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Evangela

This game is lack of item usage due to the expensive potions issue and Phoenix Down is not in the game yet

Is it possible to make it cheaper? or make recipes easier for Alchemist?

---

Recipes for Alchemy are already easy as pie, The issue is the game is not hard enough to warrant or Justify the use of said items. SE really needs to design Dungeons and future content with Item usage in mind.

I never understood why consumables in the FF MMORPGs are completely underwhelming. In FFXI there were a handful of consumables that were used for zerg attempts and solos, but the majority of potions and what not were completely worthless. FFXIV is even worse because of the current state of the game.

Ideally, I think consumables should not be universal nor items. I think Potions, Ethers, Antidotes, etc. should be "skills" for a unique class that revolves around them. You could design a really cool healer or debuffer type role that solely relies on the classic Final Fantasy items.

They really should be on par with a cure so that DOWs can consider using them instead of using action point for cure/sacrifice.
It would also be nice to make them (or a similar item) usable on party members in much the same fashion as single player rpgs

I know there's always the constant fight about FFXIV shouldn't necessarily be alike to its predecessor, and this kind of falls in that category.

But I would like to say that what FFXI had wasn't potions done wrong. It was simply different then what is mainstream MMO. Rather than making food and potions necessary and almost cheatingly overpowered like they are in many other games. They were balanced to create separate strategies rather than simply being another way to heal. When you used a vile elixer in FFXI your strategy revolved around that vile elixer. Making potions something you simply use as a backup devalues them.

I just really don't like the idea of people relying on potions to stay alive. That's what healers are for, remember class uniqueness. This is a problem especially when you have pvp to think about. Keep that to temporary items or something, I don't want the winner to be who stalked up on more potions.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Lyndis

I know there's always the constant fight about FFXIV shouldn't necessarily be alike to its predecessor, and this kind of falls in that category.

But I would like to say that what FFXI had wasn't potions done wrong. It was simply different then what is mainstream MMO. Rather than making food and potions necessary and almost cheatingly overpowered like they are in many other games. They were balanced to create separate strategies rather than simply being another way to heal. When you used a vile elixer in FFXI your strategy revolved around that vile elixer. Making potions something you simply use as a backup devalues them.

I just really don't like the idea of people relying on potions to stay alive. That's what healers are for, remember class uniqueness. This is a problem especially when you have pvp to think about. Keep that to temporary items or something, I don't want the winner to be who stalked up on more potions.

---

This pretty much. I only used potions for maat fight. Potions are only good in forced solo areas not for leveling. Most mmo I played potions were not that big. And that is the point. The point of mmo is to do stuff with other players. To have fun aand make friends.

In rectro spec. With fields of valor they made potions from chests really potent. This was to help those who solo.

Planned for either 1.19 or 1.20 I believe.