Last week I needed like 90 tomes to cap. Instead of 2 Experts, I decided to run 3 skallas since I still am hunting the tank gear that I think was removed from the loot tables. When people say that people just "highlight the bad runs" and ignore the good ones, this is for you. This is right after I finished my expert roulette and Hells Lid took 32 minutes because of a NIN you couldn't believe unless I showed it to you. Full i340 and some i350, less than 2k dps overall.
The results are as follows:
Run #1:
https://i.imgur.com/eZnHEt6.jpg
Both DPS are approx. 320 ilvl. The healer is approx. i310. Good WHM.
Run #2:
https://i.imgur.com/lmIMRkF.jpg
Man, this run really drained me.
All 3 players were approx i330.
Run #3:
https://i.imgur.com/EMuYxKT.jpg
SMN was i340. SAM was i300 (weapon and most gear). SCH was i310.
Bonus round:
O6N:
https://i.imgur.com/6aSX4cA.jpg
Almost took me as long to clear on normal as it does on Savage...
Well you can still wipe a few times and not, and it still be a net gain. But that's just semantics lol.
As an experienced tank (and mDPS) I'm fairly good at judging ilvl into translated performance. I make mistakes, they almost never lead to wipes though. I can't recall the last time I wiped in a dungeon.
It is possible he knew that the tank who was not even stance dancing was doing the most DPS? I mean hell, I know I've asked for tether as a PLD all the time. In my Hells Lid example up above the DRG was giving it to the NIN and I said you're MUCH better off giving it to me. he obliged.
