Originally Posted by
Catwho
No, the WoW exodus mattered because those players left WoW in 2021, had an 8 year content backlog to play with in XIV, and didn't go back to WoW until after Dragonflight released and the hardcore WoW players who stuck around convinced them it was good. That was in 2023.
They played Dragonflight, got bored, and bounced back over to XIV just in time for Dawntrail. That was the peak. But now they were caught up, and didn't have 8 years of content to compress into 2 years like before.
When the community turned into a negative feedback loop, a lot of them just quit both games and went to go do other stuff. Now WoW is getting the big housing update, and those former WoW players are hyped about it, while XIV isn't getting any big shiny new systems besides.... Viera hats.