God this thread is funny.
People actually think micromanaging that slow fairy separates good scholars from bad? Laughable. All you need to do is be aware of what your fairy does and fill in the gaps. Yeah, you can get minor efficiencies by placing your fairy - but that's all they are, minor.
The difference between a WHM and SCH is pretty simple. A WHM reacts to a battle, a SCH manages it. That means the SCH has to be thinking ahead whereas the WHM needs to know how to react to things. Their difference in throughput requires that difference in playstyle.
As for people that don't think SCH are used on Titan HM or anything...well, you are wrong.
EDIT:
Just to add a bit, I have done Titan HM and I did save a healer (who gets major props, it was very well played) who had resurrection sickness during phase changes. So please, enough with the SCH bashing. We are fine.
