Originally Posted by
BruceyBruceyBangBang
It wasn't only that. It was because his choices seemed irrational and content was usually unbalanced. Content that didn't make any sense and void of practicality. Just a bunch of crappy systems that either had too many hoops to jump through or content that lacked challenge. Nothing in between.
Getting something balanced in terms of content under Tanaka during FFXI and in FFXIV was never a safe bet the first time around. Then when revisions finally came for said content, people were already over it and moved onto something else. It was quite obnoxious, frankly.