Quote Originally Posted by Alhanelem View Post
I never claimed dallas was right on this, and I wasn't the one who made the comparison in the first place? So why aren't you attacking him instead of me?
I am.

I never said attack capped at 999. I said attack capped. cRatio caps. 2.2 for 2-handers. WAR doesn't need minuets to easily cap cRatio on a lot of things, assuming Berserk (fair enough since we're already assuming Smn/Sam and War/Sam are using Hasso which is native too). Since I pulled in bards, we may as well give the Smn Minuets in addition to marches just to be nice. Should we SV them too for fun? You're still looking at only 840~ attack if you assume 550 with RCB SMN/SAM.

No. That's not negligible.

Again, I'll say for the dozenth time, SMN hitting things is better than SMN not hitting things. SMN hitting things isn't total suck. But SMN hitting things cannot effectively compare its personal DD power to a "true" DD. It absolutely cannot. Be it WAR, or MNK, or NIN, or DRG. They will do more damage, and have a greater overall utility (aside from DRG).

Does that mean SMN is total ass? Meh. Depends on who you ask. It'll always be better than a total gimpcrap player. But comparing yourself to a gimpcrap player, or a DRK of any kind, is like kicking a toddler and bragging about winning the fight.