Results 1 to 10 of 123

Hybrid View

  1. #1
    Player wish12oz's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2011
    Location
    @marnie
    Posts
    1,254
    Quote Originally Posted by Brigandier View Post
    While I agree that your suggestions might help make Yonin/Innin better from a "making ninja more powerful" perspective, the questions SE has to answer really come down to "How broken are we actually going to make this job?", "what direction do we want to take this job?"
    The buffs proposed would only make ninja closer to being on even footing on easy mobs in terms of damage it can deal when compared to the top tier Melees. On harder mobs even with these adjustments ninja would still be lacking. The only proof of this I can offer is the Ukons in my einherjar LS do about 25% more damage then my ninja, and I have perfect tp/ws gear, while they are close to perfect, but not there, they can actually improve a bit, I cannot. The crit rate increase from using Innin full time would even that out on weak mobs, like those in einherjar, but for harder mobs ninja would still suffer from the lack of attack, the long delay between WS's compared to other jobs, and the low WS damage in comparison to melee damage. WAR for instance is about a 40%melee/60%ws damage split. Ninja is the opposite, 60/40 and only if you have blade: Hi, if you're using jin its more like 70%melee 30%ws.

    Not to mention the fact that Jin and Hi are both only good if they can crit, which is exceedingly hard on higher lvl mobs, because capping dDEX can become difficult, and outside of atmas, your crit rate caps at 25% from ddex/merits, and with gear you can really only push it to 39%, allowing the use of innin would help tremendously with WS's as well for harder mobs where you cant cap ddex and lose that 20% crit rate.

    Quote Originally Posted by Brigandier View Post
    You've pointed out the biggest issue with Ninja (and a few other jobs) at the end of your post. Ninja is getting use because it's able to do numerous things well; however, when the nerf happens or the jobs we replaced get buffed we're going to be right back on the "do not invite" list. What Ninja needs is something it does *best*, something that no other job can do. In fact, all jobs should have a niche that no other job can fill. Considering how the abyssea proc system works (and the new weird dynamis JA procs) it's easy to see that SE is trying to give everyone a reason to bring along that "other job" when they otherwise wouldn't. There just isn't enough job class disparity, and this is why most career NINs are stupid to not have a job that does have that "special something" like Treasure Hunter.
    There doesn't need to be any sort of nerf or buff to other jobs to make ninja go back to the bottom, all SE has to do is add slightly harder mobs then there is right now.

    Ninja already has it's niche btw, it's the DD tank. When you need something that can do damage and keep hate and not take tons of damage, ninja is the go-to job, but only if the mobs are weak, ninja fails completely on anything it can't melee well enough to keep hate off other melees. Good post though.
    (2)
    Last edited by wish12oz; 06-04-2011 at 06:21 AM.

    http://www.twitch.tv/wish12oz
    http://www.youtube.com/user/r5n/videos

Tags for this Thread