Puppetmaster's Asuran Fists <Where?>

[Alhanelem]

I didn't say anything about what pup can/can not do.

You've said plenty about it. You've basically said the magic frame is useless and no one would ever want to or should use it.

If you've been a 75+ pup for that long why would you not want access to another blue stagger that your favorite job currently lacks in it's main combat skill?

Because, for the 14th time, I don't need it, and another blue proc would not make me any more popular. The only thing I'm going to be on PUP for is either to kill things or to provide a little flexible support. No one asks a PUP because they can proc something, and adding one more blue proc is [SIZE=7]not[/SIZE] going to change that.

The only thing that COULD change that is giving PUP skill in more weapons, or giving the master more direct control over which spells the automaton casts (to be able to proc all the BLM yellow procs)

Regardless, you're still going to see mostly WAR/MNK/NIN doing blue because between these three (technically WAR and NIN can do them all but MNK can do many of them and is more popular) they have all the weapons covered.