
Originally Posted by
Seriha
Untrue. Other jobs had soloed most other things RDM had, oftentimes more quickly. Holding back a job from updates because you fear they'll solo other new things is folly. Rather, if SE is afraid of someone soloing their new precious NM, they need to design it so you can't. Rage timers, regens, regains, limited combat area, draw-in, fixing pinning, shadow-passing TP moves or ranged attacks, etc..
Not really. BRDs and CORs were superior refreshers back in the day, and anyone who felt RDMs healed better than WHMs had only dealt with bad WHMs (Who only got more powerful with /SCH and Solace/Misery). Slow and Para could also be handled by WHMs, so the low-man argument is kinda moot since I doubt people tried thanks to the RDM TP burn bandwagon. Put simply, the job isn't needed for anything now and in its current incarnation is basically third-rate everything, if not worse (especially in the melee department).
There's some justified concern floating around. Sure, you'll get the trolling counterpoints to try and goad people into fights about it, but people aren't inviting RDMs to proc, main heal over WHMs in Abyssea, buff whore, nuke, melee, or even solo crap for them. And if they are, it's a last resort kind of deal or other primary roles are covered. Regardless, no job should have to solo to try and adhere to its concept.