I don't think you know anything about tanking.
Both jobs are equal against magic for onePld had the advantage of higher base def, and good magic def so that-shadows or no-they simply got hurt less by a hit.
Nin has an edge over pld because one shadow equals to no damage and secondly because nin is contributing greatly to damage.
What's left ? ONLY mobs that you don't DD pretty much and/or would kite. On those pld has an edge over nin sure but on the other hand rdm had an edge over pld (as well as plenty of other jobs, btw, you could "tank" Kirin or JoL on blm at least a few minutes lolz). There were situations where pld was useful, I remember see farming, not necessarely for tanking but rather to clear the path and zone the mobs, to hold some NMs until other die, supertanking situations, suicidal attempts to take AV down etc.
/war is only useful for defender. Provoke generates less hate than a single melee round from a DD and it decays over time too. Melee rounds have anything from 2 ot 8 second cooldown while provoke is 30 second recast. A nin will always generate more hate than pld execpt the above situations (and by extension better DDs than nin would).They also had more hate grabbing tools, especially /war.
Last edited by MarkovChain; 05-24-2011 at 08:42 AM.
Ultimate DPS simulator
https://docs.google.com/file/d/0B7wbcilaHsTecldhZm94a1gtZnM/edit
PLD was only the best for the weak and gimps. NIN could tank most of the same mobs pld could, those it couldn't rdm/nin was better then both. Hey but they already tried to bring pld back by nerfing NIN/drk RDM/nin.
RDM/NIN was never a good tank though except very little situations so nothing important was lost.
Ultimate DPS simulator
https://docs.google.com/file/d/0B7wbcilaHsTecldhZm94a1gtZnM/edit
Its was far better then crapy turtle plds, with more tools to live though most mobs. Also forgot sam can be jsut as good of a tank on old HNM then pld.
I wish SE would step up and have the guts to do something unorthodox for once. Every other MMO has blood tanking as the main focus. Constantly avoiding DMG or taking so few DMG, kinda lessens the importance of "Healing" type jobs.
悪島 Where the spirit of the moon resides... 気 愛 月光
悪島 Where the spirit of the moon resides... 気 愛 月光
I think Abyssea was pretty unorthodox. To say they haven't done anything unorthodox is just incorrect. They took out a lot of unnecessary time sinks which was embedded in nearly every event (Tags, Campaign rank up, 24 repops, X-days cooldown, etc) and made something very accessible that didn't require a huge LS to be competitive. They've already done something drastic and I hope they continue doing so.
Yes, I am beaten. And I admit my defeat. Using the word "unorthodox" was stupid.
What I meant to say was, it's not common for other MMO's to drastically change the definition of certain classes/jobs. Completely re-working NIN to make it into a "jack of all trades" type DD (as it was originally intended to be), would be "unorthodox" in respect to how other MMO's would approach the issue.
Last edited by Akujima; 05-25-2011 at 08:51 AM.
悪島 Where the spirit of the moon resides... 気 愛 月光
|
|
© SQUARE ENIX FINAL FANTASY, SQUARE ENIX, and the SQUARE ENIX logo are registered trademarks of Square Enix Holdings Co., Ltd. Vana'diel , Tetra Master, PLAYONLINE, the PLAYONLINE logo, Rise of the Zilart, Chains of Promathia, Treasures of Aht Urhgan, and Wings of the Goddess are registered trademarks of Square Enix Co., Ltd. The rating icon is a registered trademark of the Entertainment Software Association. All other trademarks are the property of their respective owners. Online play requires internet connection. |