I don't know about WAR. I rather keep my Ravager's Gorget. And I have a Snow/Breeze Gorget for WS, so its not like I need one for that either.

Crit +5% might prove more useful for Consistency, and as a better WS neck at least outside Abyssea where you will need more Crit+ Gear than you would need inside.

for TP, eeeehhhh.... STR+something Dbl.Atk+2 vs 5Crit rate... I don't know enough to make a good estimate on that.