Common Courtesy

[Khiinroye]

The deal was

"I'll give you the chance to lot on the Tongue if it drops, in return I get your shank."

Pewpeww meant
"I'll give you the (chance to lot on the Tongue if it drops), in return I get your shank."
wherein the shank is forfeit either way.

The OP thought he was agreeing to

"I'll give you the chance to (lot on the Tongue if it drops), in return I get your shank."
wherein the tongue would need to drop to for the trade.

Same word order, different interpretations, both valid. Clarify next time.

It should have been "The first tongue that drops on our orbs is yours, but we get your shank whether or not it drops."