Quote Originally Posted by blowfin View Post
P.S. It was a terrible deal for the OP whichever way you look at it. Until he warped out.
OP said himself he doesn't care for a Defending Ring. Which means, he's only after the tongue. Which means, it was a good deal.

Quote Originally Posted by Math
YOYD:
25% chance for tongue
Chance at KB: 5%
Assuming 100% chance for KB tongue drop (which is false, because SE lowered it):
Total chance to obtain a tongue is 30%

If he gives up his shank for a chance to lot the other two orbs:
1-75%^3 = 58% chance to obtain a tongue
How can you argue with that? How is that not better for him (twice as good)?

And the OP understood him wrong, that's all that happened. There's no arguing there, it's not a matter of opinion, the deal couldn't be clearer, there was no need for an additional clause "You lot tongues, we lot shanks", how hard is that to understand? Where is the ambiguity?