Quote Originally Posted by Linh View Post
Beastly Shank was part of the original deal yes. I was to be allowed to lot the BB item if it dropped on any orb (instead of only lotting it on my orb, since it is a YOYD) in return for giving up the Beastly Shank from my orb.

Following Pewpeww's logic, I was not even guaranteed the Tongue EVEN IF IT DROPS. Cuz by that logic, I'm only allowed to lot it right? Not win it.

EDIT: To answer your second question, no. It wasn't until we were at Ronfaure and after I supposedly convinced Pewpeww that Behemoth Tongue still dropped from KS99 (cuz he said it didn't anymore) that he sent me this /tell with the agreement.
This post says it all. You agreed and knew the agreement when going in. The chance to lot BB item for in exchange for your shank. I hate to say it but yes you are in the wrong here. If you had asked before getting started the question of what happens if it doesn't drop the BB item you probably wouldn't be having this issue because if you are like me you wouldn't have gone.

You still have yet to say if anyone else in the group was after the BB item as well. From my understanding this part is very unclear.

To avoid this type of thing ever happening again just do these things with friends. Its easier and far more fun this way anyway .