1. 3

2. No

And there has been people who has agreed with me.

This was what was said BEFORE the run while at Ronfaure:

"I'll give you the chance to lot on the Tongue if it drops, in return I get your shank."

Does most DEFINITELY NOT equal this "clarification":

"The deal was not for the BB item itself, but the chance for you to lot it if it drops on our orb. Even if it doesn't drop on your orb (meaning, "at all") we still get your shank."