A Ninja without Throwing...

[Karbuncle]

when something is wrong in a game and its bother you like its seem to do... take a break man seriously, you're mental health would be just better

Also, I don't know why you hate so much the idea of the shuriken, and stop the useless argument or the Katana is better and the mathematical formula... some ppl want new shuriken and if SE make some, what you gonna do? Quit FFXI?

Not a single time in this entire thread has anyone said anything close to "NO YOU CANT USE SHURIKEN STOP YOUR AN IDIOT"

My entire Argument since my first post has been Play How you want, Enjoy your Shuriken, RP to your hearts content, But as it stands, The idea of making Throwing a Viable, DD friendly, Acceptable Solution is simply unrealistic..

We don't care if you throw Shuriken, We don't care if you enjoy it, go enjoy it. We really do not care how you spend free time. The only reason this thread is ~13 Pages is because the OP denies logic. We (I) Would not care if they added a New Shuriken, I would however care if instead of a meaningful buff, We got some Ranged Accuracy Job Trait. This is what we're trying to prevent. We know Throwing is Impossible to Fix without seriously crashing the game, So we're trying to prevent SE from thinking "Oh Hey, Ninja's want Ranged Accuracy and Attack job traits and more Sange? OKAY".

Did you read anything? His posts literally start with "I hate how Ninjas doesn't RP Shuriken Enough. Fix it now".

I'll spell this out, Clearer. He's a hypocrite. he Mocks us for only wanting to do damage, while complaining he doesn't get to do enough damage with Shuriken. We don't hate him, or you for liking Shuriken. We hate that he's fighting tooth and nail for a system we've tried to explain just simply will not see a viable buff, one good enough to make it useful, without breaking the game, or nerfing NIN

We don't hate that you love Shurikens, We don't hate that you love Role-playing to Toss shurikens even those its Historically innacurate for a NIN to continually throw Shuriken during Combat which pokes a big hole in that argument, but, anyway, We do not care if you play the game and enjoy it how you want.

You want new Shurikens? Thats a reasonable argument, but i bet you your new Shuriken will either be from

A) 1 per drop from some stupid BCNM no one wants to do.

B)
Yield: 1 New Shuriken
HQ: 2 New shuriken
HQ2: 3 New Shuriken
HQ3: 3 New Shuriken.

Recipe. Goldsmithing 100
Smithing 100
Synergy 80
3x Phrygian Gold Ingot
3x Orichalcum Ingot.

Cause that's apparently good ideas for it (Hint: See Any Shuriken Recipe, and "Targeting the Captain").

Though, i would seriously commemerate if we got a new Shuriken at level 90~+ thats easily accessible. Would it make NIN throw more? not without it having 100% Critical hit rate and a base damage of 400, but it would give players like you something to toss around. Which will make more players happy.

And i'm okay with more players being happy.

I'm just not okay with people making a mockery of these forums.