First why create yet another post about PLD vs. DD, let alone one that is specifically about PLD vs. MNK when there is one already titled similarly.

Quote Originally Posted by Humie View Post
Eva MNK>PLD
If you think this is how MNK tank works you're quite mistaken as the higher your evade rate the lower your counter rate.
Quote Originally Posted by Humie View Post
Guard vs shield MNK>PLD (mnk can still guard while asleep, stuned or terrored. PLd cant shield block when under these status)
Never seen this happen while tanking or with my friend tanking on MNK.

Quote Originally Posted by Humie View Post
cures and buffs PLD>MNK but all of these cures and buffs can be given to mnk by another player giving it a hollow victory
In a pinch Cures from the PLD are nice but otherwise a waste when compared to the cost to DPS.

Quote Originally Posted by Humie View Post
DD MNK>PLD A knock out clear win by mnk
The only point that matters in your post and it has been stated several times over in the various posts on the same topic...