It depends on the jobs and if you are soloing. Party situations yes you can use the lower lvl pieces, but in solo you want as much Def and Vit etc. as you can stack. Speaking as Pup/whm & War/dnc longtime solo player, I will confirm that the Outrider pieces come out ontop for my War because of the high Vit+Chr making my CW3 give bigger cures, plus the pdt set bonus, plus the high Def. It is way better than the Karieyh+1 set I got for my War which only came out like 3 weeks ago -ish. If you are in a party with Whms such considerations don't matter to you. Similarly on Pup/whm my MP pool and refresh are important to me for kiting. So I upgrade for those things. But the new gear will be obsolete soon, was my point. More mp gear etc. which you wouldnt swap out anyway lol because you'd lose the extra mp etc.
Re; the reforged effort/reward relationship, yes it is totally out. I now got two sets of reforged I bought all 10 slots with eminence records. They are as you say very situational I agree on that.
My main point is that I used the same gear sets for years in the past, switching in some new gear here and there. So I had permanent sets that I liked using and got used to. Now whole entire sets are replaced on a monthly basis. And nobody is going to wear Manibozo, my mule has that set fulled lixered and its shit compared to the gear that came out immediately after it. Skirmish gear is still relevant but you will be tossing it also soon enough for sure.
Everyone wants new cool gear, and I'm glad SE are adding new stuff, my problem is the iLvl system and the frequency of scorched-earth updates.
