Suggestions for improvements to Geomancer

[Alhanelem]

As much as you may hate me for it, GEO needs this. *runs*

We already have that. It's called Full Circle. But it only returns part of the MP spent, based on the remaining HP of the luopan.

[Duelle]

We already have that. It's called Full Circle. But it only returns part of the MP spent, based on the remaining HP of the luopan.

Then it needs to scrap the thing about remaining HP of the luopan (which itself is probably to simulate a duration timer without the devs actually implementing one).

[Alhanelem]

Then it needs to scrap the thing about remaining HP of the luopan (which itself is probably to simulate a duration timer without the devs actually implementing one).

I don't really disagree with the HP stipulation- why should I get a full refund of the MP cost after recieving nearly the full duration of the effect?

(I don't think they would reduce the mp costs if they were to do something like that)

[Duelle]

why should I get a full refund of the MP cost after receiving nearly the full duration of the effect?

You shouldn't. That's why the link mentioned a 25% refund. And I think it would make sense to have something along those lines, separate from the timer/HP thing.

I don't think they would reduce the mp costs if they were to do something like that

Chances are the MP cost is intended to affect your set up of the luopans, much like it is with totems. Recall/Full Circle being something to help you get something back if you're forced to move. Basing the amount on the remaining HP of the luopans is dumb, IMO, and you'd be better served by a percentage refund.

[Alhanelem]

You shouldn't. That's why the link mentioned a 25% refund. And I think it would make sense to have something along those lines, separate from the timer/HP thing.
Chances are the MP cost is intended to affect your set up of the luopans, much like it is with totems. Recall/Full Circle being something to help you get something back if you're forced to move. Basing the amount on the remaining HP of the luopans is dumb, IMO, and you'd be better served by a percentage refund.

Under normal circumstances, the % HP remaining is the % duration remaining, thus the relationship between MP returned and HP makes sense, however you're punished by this system when you're in a high end event, where your luopan is likely to take damage and therefore see its duration reduced.

In short, the duration is never constant, becuase the duraiton is directly linked to the max HP of the luopan, and the max HP of the luopan is determined by your geomancy and handbell skill. thus, higher skill = longer duration (Also, healing your luopan via ability means more MP is returned) Because of this, the HP of the luopan is really the only thing they can base the return on.

Thus it isn't so simple. I agree it would be better if they simply lasted a certain duraiton, rather than their HP pool effectively being a timer, and then the luopan HP is solely about how much punishment it can take before being destroyed (I'm pretty sure the WoW totems have HP and can be destroyed, right?)

[Duelle]

I'm pretty sure the WoW totems have HP and can be destroyed, right?

Yes, they have a very small amount of health and can be destroyed.